Check
- Mark movie as favorite
- Dislike this movie
- Add movie to watchlist
- Mark movie as owned
- Check movie
- View the official lists that include Otona no miru ehon - Umarete wa mita keredo
- Visit IMDb page
Otona no miru ehon - Umarete wa mita keredo (1932)'s comments
Order by:
- Info
- In lists (412)
- Comments (11)
- Friends
- Activity
- Checks (1493)
- Favorites (158)
Add your comment
Comments 1 - 11 of 11
Siskoid
Before the war, back when Yasujirō Ozu was still making silent comedies, he won acclaim with I Was Born, But…, and to my surprise, it really does feel like a comedy all the way through (unlike, say, Passing Fancy, which straddles the line more tightly and which I affect more). A family moves to a new town, and we watch its two young boys get up to all sorts of shenanigans, mostly trying to avoid school because of bullies and easy humiliations, though within a few days, they've turned things around, cuz kids are fickle. If there's drama, it's when the boys realize their father is just a wage slave, trying to ingratiate himself to the boss and other co-workers and so on, the pulling of a veil that makes him weaker and less respectable in their eyes. Ozu prefigures this with other disappointments, as the boys' "kid logic" fails them repeatedly and shows them to be just games no matter what idea they convinced themselves of. But if their dad is any indication, they may be playing games and lying to themselves their entire lives. Comedy or drama, it's a child's eye view, well-observed and treated by Ozu. The kids are memorable and distinctive, their adventures perfectly amusing, and the parents are poignant too (you can't be unphased by the scene where they watch the boys sleep).Melvelet
Now that's a train frequency!Dieguito
The first Yasujirô Ozu's masterpiece, always approaching family issues accordingly to Japanese culture. Great movie.Seenthemostmovies
I love this movie, though came to the sad realization halfway through tha surely some of those boys may have died in WWII.onuryz
I'm really upset to see a dislike here. this movie is a gem!jmars
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IDy4RsxDuy4DGrantChandler
Should be titled "I Was Born But..."It says it right on the cover and picture...
locovoco
It's 5 Tsuki No Beri Chiho No Muryo Haishin! In other words: Mayberry, Rural Free Delivery Japan style! You could have plopped these kids right in with Opie and Johnny Paul and Andy and Barney woulda sher given em sum good learnin'ClassicLady
Watched it again with English subtitles. What a sweet movie! Loved it!UnEnfantPerdu
Wondering why I hadn't this checked.ClassicLady
I would have liked it so much better if it had English inter titles so I could tell what was going on. Still, cinematography was wonderful.